Star Parker: Gov. Hutchinson’s Distortion of President Reagan

Republican Gov. Asa Hutchinson of Arkansas raised ire from conservatives for vetoing legislation passed by the Arkansas state legislature that would have banned “gender-affirming” medical treatment for transgender minors.

This includes treatment such as hormone therapy, puberty blockers and surgery associated with gender identity.

The legislature then overrode Hutchinson’s veto, making Arkansas the nation’s first state to ban these procedures.

Of particular interest is Hutchinson’s rationalization of his veto; he defined it as a conservative stance and used former President Reagan to justify his thinking.

Hutchinson argued during a TV interview that allowing government to prohibit these procedures pushes up against conservative principles of limiting the role of government.

“I go back to Ronald Reagan, to principles of our party, which believes in a limited role of government,” he said. “Are we as a party abandoning a limited role of government and saying we’re going to invoke the government decision-making over and above physicians, over and above health care, over and above parents — and saying, ‘You can’t do that. You cannot engage in it’?”

Reagan was a conservative president who did indeed want to limit government’s control of our private lives. But the word is “limit,” not “erase.”

Let’s consider Reagan’s words in one of his most famous speeches, known as the “evil empire” speech, which he delivered to the National Association of Evangelicals on March 8, 1983.

In that speech, Reagan called the then-Soviet Union “an evil empire” and cast the struggle between the U.S. and the USSR as a struggle of good against evil. He saw communism as evil because of its explicit godlessness.

However, Reagan also used that speech to make a broader statement regarding the general question of good and evil and his own country.

“I want you to know,” he said, “that this administration is motivated by a political philosophy that sees the greatness of America in … the institutions that foster and nourish values like concern for others and respect for the rule of law under God.”

“(T)his puts us in opposition to, or at least out of step with, a prevailing attitude of many who have turned to a modern-day secularism, discarding the tried and time-tested values upon which our very civilization is based,” he said.

And here is the crux: “Sometimes their voices are louder than ours, but they are not yet a majority.”

That was 1983.

A culture in which the objective reality of male/female, man and woman, is denied — despite the clarity of this reality both in the words of the Bible and the chemical reality of the genetic code — is a godless culture that Reagan would likely call evil today, just as he called the Soviet Union evil then.

“Freedom prospers when religion is vibrant and the rule of law under God acknowledged,” Reagan said in his speech.

He quoted William Penn, saying, “If we will not be governed by God, we must be governed by tyrants.”

Conservatism should be understood literally. To “conserve” is to save and preserve the core traditional values that enable our freedom.

It is hard to believe that, as Gov. Hutchinson suggests, Reagan’s idea of limited government means standing aside as a tyrannical secularism sweeps through our nation and wiping out any remaining remnant of those traditional biblical truths.

All the more so, it is hard to believe that Reagan would see government sitting by passively and uninvolved as those values are imposed on minors, who are not even old enough to vote.

It is far more reasonable to assume that President Reagan would stand by these truths as adamantly and stalwartly with our struggles today as he did in standing up to the Soviet Union in the 1980s.

In the face of Reagan’s single-minded and uncompromising stance regarding our core values, the Soviet Union collapsed.

The same battle is being fought now in our nation. We must fight it with the same commitment if we hope to prevail.



Photo credit: By Office of Public Affairs from Washington DC – Marshals Museum and Hall of Honor Dedication-098, CC BY 2.0, link

Star Parker is the founder and president of the Center for Urban Renewal and Education and author of “Necessary Noise: How Donald Trump Inflames the Culture War and Why This is Good News for America.” She hosts a weekly show called “Cure America with Star Parker.”

Do you like this post? Sign up for more!

Check Also

Star Parker: Democrats Spend Big, and We Pay, for Their Socialist Dream

In 1983, Tom Cruise starred in the film “Risky Business.” It’s about wealthy parents in …


  1. Spot on, Star! Even people we expect like Asa, are failing to stand strong. We know what his motivation was behind that flimsely veiled attempt to explain his actions. Corporate greed run amuck and now aligning against our core values of God FIRST with country close behind. We must battle for our children and grandchildren who are being ABUSED by these radical forces. We must do all we can to send corporate America a message with our actions. Go Woke Go Broke. Shop local. Avoid big box retailers. It takes some more effort and may cost some more dollars, but united our message will slowly be made known. I have given up pro sports which I enjoyed. Found out I don’t miss it. More time for God, reading, and doing what I can to help the push back against these powerful forces that seek the destruction of our core values. We must unite and stand in the breech.

  2. Jeanie Faught RN

    These minors are not old enough to vote; they can not consent to take an aspirin at school; they can not legally buy alcohol or tobacco. Yet this industry has determined that they can make a decision of life-changing proportions. I can’t help but think that President Reagan’s stance would be a familiar one–“as ye do for the least of these, so do you do for Me”. It is our duty to protect the least and most vulnerable among us.