Quantcast
Home / U.S. News / What A Supreme Court Justice Just Said About Obama's Amnesty Plan

What A Supreme Court Justice Just Said About Obama's Amnesty Plan

illegalaliensprotestA coalition of 26 states, led by Texas, contends that President Barack Obama overstepped his constitutional powers when he issued an executive order deferring the deportation of millions of illegal aliens. The coalition also accuses the president of violating the Take Care Clause, which charges him to “take care” that laws are faithfully executed.

The coalition asked a federal court to temporarily blocked the amnesty plan, which the court granted. The U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments in the case today. If the high court deadlocks, which seems likely, the lower court’s ruling against the president’s amnesty plan stands.

What swing-voter Justice Anthony Kennedy said today about the executive action might signal trouble for the president’s strategy to circumvent the U.S. Congress on the federal issue of immigration. From the Washington Times (emphasis added):

Outside the court, thousands of Hispanic-rights protesters rallied, demanding legal status from the courts and vowing political retribution on Congress — and Republicans in particular — if Mr. Obama loses his case.

Inside the courtroom, however, the argument was lower-key, with the justices sparring with lawyers over the tricky interplay between the law, federal regulations and Mr. Obama’s hopes of shielding most illegal immigrants from deportation.

“It’s as if the president is setting the policy and Congress is executing it. That’s just upside-down,” said Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, who is expected to be an important voice as the court decides what to do.

Photo credit: SEIU International (Creative Commons) – Some Rights Reserved

Check Also

Three Girls Complained About Running Track Against Boys — Here’s What the Dept of Education Is Doing About It

Three teenage girls who run track in high school filed a complaint with the U.S. …

3 comments

  1. Reminds me of DOMA. Obama said he would not enforce it, even though he took an oath to enforce ALL our laws.

    • So, we need a president who is a constitutionalist, who is conservative, and does what he says he will do. I wonder who fits that description ? ?

  2. There is some intelligence on the SCOUS. Judge Kennedy is totally correct! It’s time the SCOUS begins tnterpreting the law instead of trying to making the law. The sooner the GREAT LEADER of THE CIVILIZED WORLD understands that; the better of we will be. Also, it’s time Congress/Senate do their jobs and make/change laws instead of abdicating their responsibility to the GREAT LEADER.